The core techniques of tulpamancy that work for development never stop working later on. But, for developed and accomplished systems, they might start to seem silly and unnecessary compared to just casual, natural interaction.
Luminesce: "Time until perceived vocality" is really just a measure of how much doubt someone had. Since clear independence is a smooth spectrum of progress over time, there's really no easy checkpoint for saying "Right there, that's when my tulpa became fully developed" - and so it might never be obvious when day 1's "easily imagining my tulpa talking, I think?" turns into day 365's "My tulpa and I talk about things all the time"(edited)
1:48 AM
Though, after a long time has passed, you can look back at an early point and go "Oh, yeah no, we're way past that."
1:49 AM
Like how you don't notice a friend getting older when you see them often, but then one day you look at an old photo of them and go "Whoah, they looked totally different back then"
1:49 AM
Tulpa development is like that. How much you did or didn't doubt their ability to speak early on isn't really an important sign of progress.
1:50 AM
Just how separate they feel from you, really.
1:50 AM
And that comes with time, all you can do is keep interacting with them and intending for them to be independent
1:50 AM
Eventually, you'll notice they are
1:51 AM
(And as always, the time it takes to get there ranges from a few weeks to a year on average, but day 1 tulpas that didn't noticeably have any specific checkpoints aren't incredibly uncommon - it's just good to understand that they aren't particularly well established in your brain yet so early on)
Luminesce: Basically just keep going and don't doubt anything that seems like it could reasonably have been your tulpa, yes. Though you should say "My tulpa wouldn't say that" or "I think that was just a random unrelated thought" when appropriate as well.(edited)
1:56 AM
And I don't need any particular responses to my textwalls, though I do like to hear people feeling reassured or hopeful.
Reisen
Luminesce: Basically just keep going and don't doubt anything that seems like it could reasonably have been your tulpa, yes. Though you should say "My tulpa wouldn't say that" or "I think that was just a random unrelated thought" when appropriate as well. (edited)
Luminesce: Something like that. I don't think it's too harmful to associate totally random thoughts as "Maybe that was my tulpa!", though it is a little silly. But definitely know how to say "My tulpa wouldn't want to say that" to avoid intrusive thoughts, because believing in them makes them real in your mind (while ignoring them removes any meaning or power from them)(edited)
I have had sleeps in which i kinda remember (i believe) not stopping thinking at all and being reasoning and having monologue all night long though, but that was before being plural.
4:30 PM
So you could have something like that while being plural too maybe.
4:31 PM
When that happened i would wake up really tired the next day.
I would say that it comes and goes, like, i get them for a while, then wake up, then sleep again and have them again, and it becomes a cycle during the whole night.
I don’t think I’ve ever experienced something like that.
I have had some interesting hypnagogic experiences, though
4:43 PM
talking in a voice chat, for example.
I did hear people talking and I did physically talk to them, but there was no actual vc. When I realized what was happening, I found I had absolutely no clue what I said or heard
I have had all kinds of hynagogic hallucinations... Floating, crazy tactile sensations, rolling, rotating, the whole world getting compressed, being killed...
I honestly think it's just as simple as "Intend for a separate person to be being created in your brain, talk to them believing they're listening, and try expecting to hear responses from them"
To be clear, I don't think guides are necessary at all. Just some basic guidelines, in the form of basic advice + expectations.
3:42 AM
I think people get WAY too hung up on "following X guide"
3:42 AM
Honestly I don't believe in "following guides" in the first place. I believe in gaining information about the experience, about good practices and what (options there are) to expect.
Original message was deleted or could not be loaded.
IIRC he’s more into the sexual aspects of tulpamancy, which I tend to be against unless the relationship forms over time and naturally, as opposed to like, making someone solely for that reason.